Our Picks for the Best Natural Toothpaste That Actually Cleans
Publushed by:
Lorraine PinnixLast updated:
March 5, 2022
EDITOR’S CHOICE
Himalaya Whitening Toothpaste
Unique cleaning
Bleach-free
Cruelty-free
CHECK LATEST PRICE
EDITOR’S CHOICE
Auromere Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste
Award winning
Gluten-free
Non GMO
CHECK LATEST PRICE
EDITOR’S CHOICE
Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Toothpaste
Strengthens teeth
No preservatives
Cavity protection
CHECK LATEST PRICE
Your pearly whites need a lot of love and attention to keep them healthy and clean, and if you’re someone who uses natural products, this can be harder to do. While there are great natural tubes of toothpaste out there, it’s a challenge finding ones that actually clean as well as they’re supposed to.
What’s in natural toothpaste? Natural toothpastes refer to those made with fewer harsh ingredients and chemicals, relying on natural ones like baking soda and coconut oil instead. There’s no definition of what natural toothpaste has to be, with some people wanting fluoride-free and others preferring fluoride.
To help you navigate your way through the natural toothpaste market, we’ve selected just a handful that are worth checking out. If you’re ready to make the switch to a more natural approach to teeth cleaning, see what the modern age of natural dental hygiene is all about.
Whether it’s the best natural whitening toothpaste or the best natural toothpaste for gum disease, there are a lot of options to consider. We’ve picked just a handful of the most highly rated natural toothpastes to cover every category, so you have only the best to choose from.
Best Overall: Himalaya Whitening Toothpaste
Short summary
Whitening Antiplaque Toothpaste from Himalaya features plant based enzymes from papaya and pineapple to clean your teeth, mint for flavoring and nothing harsh like SLS or triclosan included.
Himalaya’s Whitening Antiplaque Toothpaste is a natural way to clean your teeth and gums, without any of the nasty ingredients you usually find.
Coming in a four pack with 5.29oz tubes, there’s more than enough to last you for a year or natural tooth brushing, and in a cruelty free, SLS free, and fluoride free formula. Designed for kids and adults, you can use this on ages six and up for a more natural but deep clean of the teeth and gums.
Although natural, people were shocked to find how well this toothpaste foamed up and gave their teeth a thorough cleaning. As a whitening product, you’ll be able to see results in just a few weeks without having to use bleach.
The happy customers had many comments from others on how much brighter their teeth were not long after they started using Himalaya. Better still, it achieves all of this with natural ingredients like mint, pineapple, and papaya extract.
Himalaya’s Whitening Antiplaque Toothpaste is suitable for ages six and up and comes at a very affordable price in a pack of four.
However, there is stevia extract used in this toothpaste and the taste is noticeable, so if you prefer to steer clear of the sweetener then there are others to try. For natural goodness and a deep cleaning and whitening of your teeth, our favorite find is from Himalaya.
Quick Facts
- Size: 5.29oz (pack of 4)
- Flavor: Mint
- Age Range: 6+
Pros
- The whitening effect of this toothpaste is real and people have noticed compliments about how much whiter their teeth are since using it.
- Natural extracts like papaya and pineapple work at cleaning and brightening the teeth better than any chemicals could.
- It’s reasonably priced for a four pack of toothpaste and will last you for the whole year if you’re using it yourself.
- The formula is free of SLS and fluoride for people who are cautious about what they’re cleaning their teeth with.
- Just a small amount of toothpaste creates a good foam so you only need a little to clean your whole mouth.
Cons
- The presence of Stevia extract was noticed by people who are sensitive to these types of sweeteners, especially in their toothpaste, so be mindful of it.
- Although marketed as organic, only a few of the ingredients can actually be classed as organic, which is sort of misleading.
Runner-Up: Auromere Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste
Short summary
Auromere Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste is an award-winning natural toothpaste made with 24 different herbal extracts including neem and peelu. This two pack of 4.16oz toothpaste tubes is highly concentrated, made with no fluoride, SLS, dyes, gluten, or artificial sweeteners.
Auromere has created an Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste to replace your regular toothpaste, and ditched all of the harsh ingredients that you don’t need.
Instead, their clean toothpaste features essential oils and botanical extracts, delivering a deeper clean and removing plaque and germs from your teeth and gums. People loved to find there were no SLS, dyes, colors, sweeteners, or fluoride in this toothpaste, making it a truly natural alternative.
The Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste is intense and minty, with users reporting a feeling of freshness that lasted for hours. Best of all, they don’t include any artificial sweeteners to make the flavor, so it’s all fresh mint and other essential oils that you’re tasting.
As well as the usual ingredients, you’ll find unique ones like neem, peelu, cinnamon bark oil, and pomegranate rind, so there’s a lot of good stuff working for you.
Their concentrated formula means just a little bit of toothpaste goes a long way, but cost wise, it’s one of the most expensive that we’ve reviewed so it might be out of some people’s budgets.
Additionally, the tube is one of the smallest in the natural toothpaste market, so you’ll need to replenish your stock more regularly. If you only want the cleanest ingredients to clean your teeth, there’s nothing like Auromere’s Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste.
Quick Facts
- Size: 4.16oz (pack of 2)
- Flavor: Mint
- Age Range: Adults
Pros
- Auromere comes with a harsh minty taste that lasts for hours in your mouth and makes every clean feel as fresh as possible.
- As a concentrated formula, you only need a small drop of this toothpaste to clean your entire mouth.
- There’s nothing artificial added to this toothpaste which means no fluoride, gluten, colors, dyes, or anything else.
- Uses 24 different herbal extracts to clean, remove plaque, fight germs, and do everything a toothpaste should.
- There are no sweeteners added which means the flavors are all natural as well, and it doesn’t have a funny aftertaste.
Cons
- This is one of the more expensive options for herbal toothpaste and comes in a much smaller tube as well.
- It doesn’t appear to be suitable for children, so only adults will get to use this herbal toothpaste.
- The mint flavor of this can be intense for some, and if you’re used to a bit of sweetener in your toothpaste to dull it, you’ll probably find Auromere’s to be too much.
Alternative: Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Toothpaste
Short summary
Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Toothpaste is a natural anti-cavity toothpaste that features fluoride to strengthen the teeth, and it comes in a three pack of 4oz tubes. It’s vegan friendly and cruelty free, plus made right here in the USA.
Tom’s of Maine has created their Whole Care Toothpaste as a cavity fighting formula for the whole family.
Suitable for ages two years and up, it’s gentle enough for everyone to use, and it features nothing concerning like artificial colors and flavors, bleaches, SLS, or parabens. Coming in three 4oz tubes, this toothpaste pack also has four distinct flavors, including Cinnamon Clove, Peppermint, Spearmint, and Winter Mint.
As the best natural toothpaste with fluoride included, you’re getting the best of both worlds. The benefits of fluoride for your teeth with the gentleness that a natural toothpaste provides are both there.
However, those wanting something fluoride free will need to keep shopping. Tom’s of Maine ensures their products are vegan, cruelty free, and contain nothing harsh like dyes, parabens, polyethylene glycol, or artificial flavors and colors, so you can feel good about choosing them.
This toothpaste has a mild mint flavor that leaves your mouth fresh without being too much, and it features ingredients like bicarb soda and calcium carbonate to clean your teeth.
Although the peppermint flavor costs a little more, people are happy to pay because of just how effective it is for a natural product. Tom’s of Maine produces and packages everything in the US, and their products are cruelty free and vegan, so you’ll feel good choosing them.
Quick Facts
- Size: 4oz (pack of 3)
- Flavor: Winter Mint, Cinnamon Clove, Peppermint, Spearmint
- Age Range: 2+
Pros
- This toothpaste is gentle enough to be used by children as young as two, as long as it’s done responsibly, so the whole family can enjoy.
- This is the best natural fluoride toothpaste that gives the added benefits of this ingredient while still choosing something that’s cleaner and better for you.
- Tom’s of Maine makes their products in the US so you’re supporting a local brand when you buy from them.
- People who’ve had issues with cavities or want to prevent them in their children will love the strengthening benefits of this toothpaste.
- It has a delicious minty flavor that’s not too overpowering and doesn’t use any artificial flavors to achieve.
Cons
- As a 4oz tube, there isn’t much to this toothpaste, and as it’s not a concentrated formula, you will go through each one pretty quickly.
- While there are benefits to having fluoride in toothpaste, those wanting a fluoride free alternative won’t want to choose this one.
- The peppermint flavor is more expensive than the others, and the most popular, so be prepared to pay a few dollars more for a three pack.
Alternative: Dr. Sheffield’s Certified Natural Toothpaste
Short summary
Dr. Sheffield has created a Certified Natural Toothpaste made with natural ingredients, and it comes in a handy pack of two 5oz tubes. Certified by the Natural Products Association and with the trust of a 170-year-old brand behind it.
Dr. Sheffield’s Certified Natural Toothpaste comes from the brand behind the invention of the toothpaste tube, and for 170 years they haven’t changed their formula.
This toothpaste is certified natural by the Natural Products Association and doesn’t contain any preservatives, colors, flavors, sweeteners, or synthetic foaming agents. Dr. Sheffield is credited with making the first toothpaste in a tube and has continued their quest to make clean and natural products for the home.
In each pack, you’ll get two tubes of natural toothpaste coming in a 5oz size, and you can choose between a huge selection of flavors like mixed berry and mint.
The Whitening Natural Mint is a best seller and both freshening and whitening. Those with sensitive palettes should avoid the Natural Chocolate as it’s a little sickening, and the mixed berry can be a lot as well.
Unfortunately, the mint toothpaste is only suitable for adults, so you can’t share it with your kids unless you choose another flavor.
These toothpastes are cruelty free and contain no fluoride, but do an amazing job of whitening your teeth in no time at all, with people seeing results in a month or two.
Dr. Sheffield is a trusted name in the world of natural toothpaste and with good reason, but be prepared to pay a little more for their premium reputation. If you want truly natural toothpaste and a product that’s truly natural, their Certified Natural Toothpaste is one of the best.
Quick Facts
- Size: 5oz (pack of 2)
- Flavor: Whitening Natural Mint, Natural Chocolate and more
- Age Range: Adults
Pros
- There’s a huge selection of flavors and types of toothpaste to choose from within this range.
- If you want whiter teeth, this is the toothpaste to choose, with people seeing results in just a couple of months.
- This brand has been making toothpaste for 170 years and they’re one of the most popular names out there, even being credited with inventing the toothpaste tube.
- You’ll find zero toxins within this toothpaste so there’s no need to scan the ingredients looking for anything nasty.
- There’s nothing fancy added to this toothpaste so if you want a simple but effective product, it’s the way to go.
Cons
- This is an expensive natural toothpaste when you compare it with the rest, so you have to really love its benefits.
- The other flavors aren’t as good as the natural mint, so you’ll probably want to steer clear of the chocolate toothpaste.
- You won’t be able to share every toothpaste in this range with the whole family as it’s only suitable for adults.
Alternative: Hello Antiplaque and Whitening Toothpaste
Short summary
Hello’s Antiplaque and Whitening Toothpaste comes in a four pack of 4.7oz tubes with toothpaste that’s been formulated to brush away plaque and whiten your teeth without any harsh chemicals.
Hello has made a name for themselves in the natural toothpaste market and their Antiplaque and Whitening Toothpaste is a fan favorite.
This is a fluouride free toothpaste that uses farm grown peppermint, coconut oil and tea tree oil to do the work of your usual toothpaste, with nothing hidden in there that could be bad for your teeth.
There are some minor downsides, including the fact that it doesn’t contain foaming agents which means you have to use more of the toothpaste.
You’ll also note that it’s slightly more expensive than the others, so you have to be loyal to the brand. This aside, it actually does what it’s meant to and delivers a seriously deep clean you can feel, plus gives whiter teeth in just a few weeks.
This four pack of 4.7oz toothpaste will last a while, but it’s not kid-friendly. Hello makes a whole range of toothpastes for kids and adults though, and all of them are made in the USA, vegan friendly, and cruelty free, so you can put your faith in them.
If your teeth need a deeper clean, the four pack of Hello Antiplaque and Whitening Fluoride Free Toothpaste is the way to go.
Quick Facts
- Size: 4.7oz (pack of 4)
- Flavor: Mint
- Age Range: Adults
Pros
- This toothpaste delivers one of the deepest cleans of all of the natural toothpastes for people who want to remove plaque properly.
- Hello has a solid reputation and their entire range of natural toothpaste is always rated as some of the best.
- There are no artificial sweeteners or colors, plus none of the other nasty stuff, so you’ll feel good about using this natural alternative.
- As a whitening toothpaste, people reported seeing a difference in just a few weeks, plus had compliments from others.
- Hello packages these in larger tubes so you get more product, and having a four pack means less ordering in the future.
Cons
- These are only slightly more expensive than the competition, but for some people, they're paying for the brand reputation that Hello has.
- This toothpaste doesn’t froth up so you need to apply more product than regular toothpaste for it to cover your whole mouth.
- This can’t be used by the kids in your family so you’ll need to buy them a separate Hello toothpaste.
Natural Toothpaste FAQ
Making the switch to natural toothpaste can be daunting, especially if you’re concerned about the quality of the clean it can provide. To ease your mind and help you choose the right toothpaste, we’ve answered some FAQs that’ll teach you the basics.
Is Natural Toothpaste Good For Your Teeth?
There are natural toothpaste options that are good for your teeth, and sometimes better than regular toothpaste, but not all of them are.
Choosing a natural toothpaste that contains the right ingredients to clean and strengthen your teeth is important, and for some, this might mean one with fluoride.
How Can I Clean My Teeth Without Toothpaste?
If you don’t have access to toothpaste and need a short term alternative, you can try rubbing some baking soda and water paste on your teeth.
Otherwise, chewing on crunchy vegetables, chewing sugarless gum, or rinse your mouth with mouthwash until you’re able to brush them again.
What Did People Use Before Toothpaste?
Before toothpaste was invented, products made of abrasive materials like crushed seashells and eucalyptus or camphor were used.
These were sold as either a tooth cream or powder but were not as effective at strengthening the teeth, cleaning away plaque, or fighting germs as modern kinds of toothpaste are.
Is Baking Soda Good For Teeth?
Baking soda is commonly found in natural tubes of toothpaste as it’s an effective cleaning agent for the teeth and delivers good results.
However, you shouldn’t use baking soda as the only ingredient for cleaning your teeth as it’s not effective at preventing decay, strengthening the teeth, or fighting germs that are inside of the mouth.
Conclusion
As we all have unique goals for our dental hygiene, there’s no simple answer for what is the best natural toothpaste.
Our recommendations cover toothpaste in every category, including whitening and sensitivity, so check out our favorites to see which direction you should take for your pearly whites.
