The Best Vegan Mayo Picks for Plant-Based Goodness
Publushed by:
Lorraine PinnixLast updated:
March 3, 2022
BEST OVERALL
Hellman’s Vegan Dressing and Spread
Non-GMO
70 Calories per serve
Affordable
CHECK LATEST PRICE
RUNNER UP
Plant Perfect Vegan Mayonnaise
Designed by chefs
Gluten-free
Great taste
CHECK LATEST PRICE
BEST FOR BUDGET
Best Foods Heavy Duty Vegan Dressing
Right consistency
Large jar
Thick texture
CHECK LATEST PRICE
When you go vegan, there are some foods that are hard to give up, including your favorite condiments. Thankfully, vegan food brands have worked hard to develop mayonnaise that tastes like the real deal but without any of the animal products, so you no longer have to go without it.
What is vegan mayonnaise made of? Vegan mayonnaise is made without any animal products, so won’t contain eggs as regular mayo does. Depending on the brand, you might find ingredients like oil, vinegar, plant-based milk, and spices, giving it the flavor and consisting of normal mayonnaise.
Finding the best tasting vegan mayo in a saturated market can be like searching for a needle in a haystack, but it doesn’t have to be that much work. We’ve selected five of our favorite vegan mayonnaise products for you to enjoy, with a little more about why we love them so.
Some vegan mayo brands do it better than others, and to save you from trying them all, we’ve rounded up the best of the best. These are our picks for vegan mayonnaise that tastes just as good as the real deal.
Best Overall: Hellman’s Vegan Dressing and Spread
Short summary
As one of the world’s most famous mayonnaise brands, Hellman’s has released their Vegan Dressing and Spread as a plant-based alternative. The ingredients of this spread include vinegar, mustard flavoring, canola oil, and it has 70 calories per serve.
Hellman’s has a reputation as being one of the tastiest mayonnaise makers in the world, and people breathed a sigh of relief when they announced their Vegan Dressing and Spread.
Coming in a convenient and affordable pack of three squeeze top bottles, this mayonnaise has no eggs, dairy, gluten, cholesterol, or artificial flavors in it.
A tablespoon serving is around 70 calories and it can be used as a versatile spread or topping for sandwiches, salads, and anything else you want to apply it to.
The worst thing about this mayonnaise was that it had a runnier texture compared to the real deal, so there will be some trial and error as you get used to putting it on sandwiches and using it as a salad dressing.
On the upside, the flavor is just as good, if not better, than regular mayonnaise and you won’t be able to tell the difference, thanks to the quality of the Hellman’s brand. You’ll need to eat it in moderation though as it has a high oil content and isn’t the healthiest thing.
With a three-pack of the spread in each order, you’ll want to make sure you’re going to eat them all before the expiration date comes, so check these when the order arrives.
You’ll love how easily it squirts out thanks to the bottle design, and it means nothing gets accidentally left behind and mixed into your mayo. Hellman’s Vegan Dressing and Spread is a versatile and cruelty free way to enjoy your favorite condiment with a flavor that’s truly unique.
Quick Facts
- Size: 3 x 11.5fl oz
- Flavor: Mayonnaise
- Package: Squeeze bottle
Pros
- At around 70 calories per serving of a tablespoon, you’ll find this is one of the healthier alternatives for vegan mayo that you don’t have to feel bad about.
- Taste-wise, this is rated as one of the better vegan mayos out there, and stays true to the Hellman’s solid reputation.
- Having a squeeze bottle and cap makes it easy to store this mayo with minimal mess.
- Every serving of this gives you a healthy dose of Omega-3 fatty acids so it’s not just a junk food style condiment.
- The price of these is a lot lower than other vegan brands, and you get a supply of three spread bottles to keep you going.
Cons
- The oil content of this mayonnaise is high and it should only be enjoyed as a sometimes treat.
- Although there are thickeners listed in the ingredients, the texture of this mayonnaise is slightly thinner than regular mayo so it might take some getting used to.
- Check the expiration dates on the bottles when they arrive, as some customers reported getting bottles that were close to theirs.
Runner-Up: Plant Perfect Vegan Mayonnaise
Short summary
Plant Perfect’s Vegan Mayonnaise is a premium plant-based mayonnaise designed by chefs and made with ingredients like soy powder, apple cider vinegar, organic canola oil, and mustard flour. Coming in a 12fl glass jar with a lid, it’s eco-friendly and reusable.
Plant Perfect has developed a plant-based mayonnaise that ticks all of the boxes and tastes like a restaurant quality condiment.
The 12fl oz glass jar is recyclable and the mayonnaise can be used on anything you want for true versatility in the kitchen. Inside the jar, you’ll find mayo that is non-GMO, gluten free, and made with loads of organic ingredients, however it does contain some soy products, so that’s worth being mindful of.
As a palm oil free vegan mayo you don’t need to worry about the contents, and Plant Perfect uses organic canola oil to get the consistency instead. Other ingredients include mustard flour, organic apple cider vinegar, and soy powder, so it’s slightly different from the competition.
People love the unmistakable mayonnaise taste and because it’s so packed with flavors, you only need a little bit spread on your sandwich to notice it.
On the downside, this mayo comes with a higher calorie count of 90 calories per serving, and the fat content is pretty high. That being said, this would be a moderation food that’s enjoyed occasionally, so there’s no need to be guilty when you have some.
Plant Perfect Vegan Mayonnaise is an expensive option but a delicious one, and if you’re craving that real mayo taste, they can certainly deliver.
Quick Facts
- Size: 12fl. oz
- Flavor: Mayonnaise
- Package: Glass jar
Pros
- Customers loved the flavor of this mayo and how it tastes just like their old favorite brand, so you can’t even tell it’s vegan.
- There’s no palm oil included in this recipe and only organic canola oil, so you can feel good about your purchase.
- Having it packaged in a glass jar means you can recycle it when you’re done and there’s less harm to the planet.
- People reported using this mayonnaise on more than just sandwiches so it’s a versatile condiment to keep at home.
- The flavors are bold so you only need to use a little to get the mayonnaise taste.
Cons
- The ingredients list shows that this contains soy which won’t be suitable for all consumers.
- The cost for a single jar of this is triple what other leading brands charge, so it can get costly if you eat a lot of mayonnaise.
- With around 90 calories in a single tablespoon serving, this appears to be one of the higher fat vegan condiments on the market.
Best for Budget: Best Foods Heavy Duty Vegan Dressing
Short summary
Best Foods’ Heavy Duty Vegan Dressing and Sandwich Spread is a one gallon jar of plant-based mayonnaise that can be used for all kinds of meals and snacks. This spread contains no artificial colors or flavors, no eggs or dairy, non-GMO sourced ingredients, no gluten, and no cholesterol.
Best Foods Heavy Duty Vegan Dressing and Sandwich Spread is one of the most affordable ways to eat plant-based condiments without any of the guilt. People loved how large this jar of mayo is with one gallon worth of spread to enjoy, and no nasty ingredients.
The Best Foods vegan mayo is made with canola oil, soybean oil, vinegar, lemon juice concentrate, and paprika, among others, but some people found that the flavors weren’t as defined. If you prefer a bold taste, using a little more should get you the tang you desire.
Those searching for a vegan mayo with a thick texture will be thrilled they’ve found the Best Foods version, as it’s not too runny like others.
Having this thicker consistency means it’s amazing on sandwiches, in salads, and used for all types of cooking, and it gives you more ways to enjoy it. However, it has a high oil content and 90 calories in a tablespoon, so be careful not to overdo it and only enjoy it in moderation.
The Best Foods Heavy Duty Vegan Dressing and Sandwich Spread is affordable and tasty, relying on no animal products or nasty ingredients to be made.
If you want a bulk supply of plant-based spread and have been looking for something thick and creamy, you’ll love this vegan alternative and the eco-friendly glass packaging it comes in.
Quick Facts
- Size: 1 gallon
- Flavor: Mayonnaise
- Package: Glass jar
Pros
- Having a gallon’s worth of mayonnaise on hand means big savings and fewer trips to the grocery store.
- This is one vegan mayo that managed to get the consistency right and it's just like the real deal.
- It’s versatile enough to use on just about anything in the kitchen and with plenty to go around.
- There are no nasty ingredients and it's non-GMO and gluten free for your peace of mind.
- The price of this vegan mayonnaise puts it at the cheaper end of the scale and it's a budget-friendly way to enjoy plant-based meals.
Cons
- This mayo doesn’t have the boldest flavor when compared to some of the others, so you may need to use a little more.
- Check the expiration date on your mayonnaise as one person eating this alone might not be able to get through it all before it expires.
- With 90 calories per serving, it's not the healthiest condiment and has a little more fat than other mayo brands.
Alternative: Chosen Foods Vegan Mayo
Short summary
Chosen Foods Vegan Mayo is part of their vegan condiment lineup and comes in a handy 12oz glass jar. This mayo is made with the finest ingredients including pure avocado oil, aquafaba, fava bean protein, mustard, and vinegar, among others, and has 90 calories per serve.
Chosen Foods is a premium condiment brand dedicated to delicious and nutritious foods, with options like roasted garlic and wasabi mayos available.
Their Classic Vegan Mayo is a popular product because of its high-quality ingredients including the use of fava bean protein and avocado oil, so if you’re looking for a mayo that’s not just fillers, this is the way to go.
With 90 calories per serve, you need to watch the higher fat content of this mayo, and only eat it in moderation.
There is a price to pay for these premium ingredients and good taste though, and you’ll find that Chosen Foods is one of the most expensive brands on the market today.
The mayonnaise comes in a 12oz glass jar so it’s recyclable, but once you’ve opened it, you’ll need to consume the contents within just two months. While they have managed to get a perfectly tangy taste and good texture, this was a bit of a letdown, especially considering the price.
This plant-based condiment tastes like the real deal but features no undesirable ingredients, so there’s no canola oil, soy products, or artificial nasties to be found.
The use of avocado oil in their range is what sets them apart, as well as expertly defined flavors that can be credited to professional chefs. If you’re happy to pay a little more and want a vegan condiment brand that knows what they’re doing, the Chosen Foods option is one of the best.
Quick Facts
- Size: 12oz
- Flavor: Wasabi, Classic, Garlic, Harissa, Lime, Keto, Vegan
- Package: Glass jar
Pros
- Chosen Foods uses pure avocado oil as the main oil in this recipe and the difference is noticeable and amazing.
- This mayo introduced people to the rest of the Chosen Foods vegan condiment line, and they were impressed with everything they tried.
- There’s no soy or canola content in this vegan mayo which is a huge bonus for those on restrictive diets.
- The flavor of this mayonnaise is out of this world and even better than the regular non-vegan condiments.
- The use of aquafaba helps to create a thicker consistency so the texture is just like the real deal.
Cons
- Some people found the price of this mayonnaise to be well out of their budget, considering it only comes in a standard size jar.
- Once you’ve opened this mayo, it can only stay in the fridge for two months, so you might not get your money’s worth.
- Check when your jar arrives that the product has not separated, or it will need to be returned for a new one.
Alternative: Harmless Eggless Mayonnaise
Short summary
Eggless Mayonnaise has been created by Harmless, a brand dedicated to cruelty free foods. Their mayonnaise is made with ingredients like vinegar, soybean oil, and salt, to replicate the real deal, but it contains no cholesterol or sugar at all.
Harmless’ Eggless Mayonnaise is a vegan spread made with soybean oil, vinegar, potato starch, and more. Featuring no eggs or animal products, non-GMO sourced ingredients, no sugar, and no cholesterol, you don’t need to feel bad about indulging yourself.
The flavor is just like the real deal and it has a thick texture, so you can spread it on just about anything and enjoy.
The price of this mayonnaise sets it apart and getting two bottles in each pack makes it even better. However, it would have been good to see glass jars instead of plastic, just so it’s gentler on the environment.
People did love how easy the squeeze bottle made it to get mayo out though, so it’s not all bad. Better still, each tablespoon of the mayo only features 50 calories, so it’s got the lowest fat content of all that we reviewed.
It’s rare to find a mayonnaise brand that offers a full money-back guarantee, but Harmless does. If you don’t love their Eggless Mayonnaise range, they’ll refund your money without any questions asked so you can try without any risk.
This brand has proven you don’t have to spend a fortune just to get tasty and cruelty free condiments, so check out the Eggless range by Harmless to see what else they offer.
Quick Facts
- Size: 2 x 12.4oz bottles
- Flavor: Garlic, Pea, Classic
- Package: Plastic bottle
Pros
- There are only 50 calories in a serving of this mayonnaise which makes it one of the healthier options we've reviewed.
- The squeeze bottle lets it stay fresher for longer and ensures you never have problems getting it out.
- It’s an incredibly cheap option that lets you enjoy cruelty free condiments without breaking the bank.
- There are three variations of their mayo including green peas and garlic so you can mix up the flavors if you want more.
- Harmless offer a money back guarantee so if you don’t love their mayonnaise they’ll refund the purchase price with no questions asked.
Cons
- This mayonnaise doesn’t appear to have a lot of organic or natural ingredients, so if you prefer to eat clean it might not be for you.
- Using plastic packaging doesn’t fit in with the message that Harmless is trying to spread, and a glass jar would have been better.
- Soybean oil has been used in this mayonnaise so if you follow a soy free diet this won’t be ideal.
Vegan Mayo FAQ
Vegan condiments are becoming more popular every day, and starting to taste a lot better as well. To learn more about vegan mayo nutrition and how it’s made, read on for a few commonly asked questions that can help.
Is Vegan Mayo Any Good?
Vegan mayonnaise, and other plant based condiments, have come so far in how they taste compared to just a few years ago. Most people cannot tell the difference between vegan and non-vegan mayonnaise when they try them, and it’s an easy substitute you can make to your diet.
Is Vegan Mayo Healthier Than Normal Mayo?
Not all vegan condiments are healthier than the non-vegan alternative, but mayonnaise may be slightly so because it has less saturated fat and cholesterol in it.
However, it does contain a sizeable amount of oil usually and should only be enjoyed as part of a balanced diet and in moderation.
What Is In Hellmann’s Vegan Mayonnaise?
Hellman’s lists the ingredients of their vegan mayonnaise on their official website, so consumers can see exactly what’s contained in it.
The ingredients include canola oil, water, sugar, vinegar, natural mustard flavor, and lemon juice concentrate, plus some thickeners and antioxidants.
Is Plant-Based Mayo Dairy Free?
Yes, most foods that are labeled ‘plant-based’ do not contain any dairy or other animal products. A plant-based mayonnaise product will usually have ingredients like oil, vinegar, and spices to replicate the flavors and textures of the original condiment but there’ll be no dairy present.
Conclusion
There’s no need to give up your favorite condiments just because you’re following a vegan diet, and with the improvement in flavors and tastes from plant-based brands, there’s no need to.
With our picks for the best vegan mayo you can try them all and enjoy some cruelty free condiments and zero guilt.
BEST OVERALL
